Brawlhalla is a widely popular free-to-play platform fighter, offering players a variety of characters with distinct weapons and movesets. One of the game’s core mechanics is its weapon-based combat, where each character (Legend) wields two different weapons. However, a recurring issue within the community is weapon balancing, as certain weapons are perceived to be overpowered, while others seem underwhelming. This article delves deep into the specific issue of weapon balancing in Brawlhalla, analyzing its impact on gameplay, the competitive scene, and how developers have addressed this challenge over the years.
Understanding Weapon Diversity in Brawlhalla
Before diving into the balance issue, it is essential to understand the diversity of weapons in Brawlhalla. Each Legend wields two of 13 different weapon types, such as swords, hammers, blasters, and scythes. Each weapon offers distinct attack ranges, speeds, and combos, leading to various playstyles.
Weapon Categories and Roles
Weapons in Brawlhalla are often categorized based on their speed, range, and attack style. For instance, the Sword is a balanced weapon with moderate speed and range, while the Hammer trades speed for high damage and knockback. These categories allow players to choose Legends that match their playstyle, be it aggressive, defensive, or zoning.
Signature Moves and Weapon Synergies
Each Legend also comes with signature moves (sigs), which are unique to their character and complement their weapons. Certain weapons, like the Spear, pair well with a variety of signatures, while others like Gauntlets require a more technical approach to capitalize on sigs effectively.
The Evolution of Weapon Balancing in Brawlhalla
Brawlhalla’s weapon balancing has evolved significantly since its release. Early in the game’s history, certain weapons were overwhelmingly dominant in both casual and competitive play.
The Era of Overpowered Weapons (2015-2017)
During the initial years, Brawlhalla faced numerous balancing challenges, with weapons like Blasters and Hammer standing out as incredibly overpowered. Their high damage output, combined with long-range hitboxes, made them extremely difficult to counter for newer players. As a result, matches felt skewed in favor of these weapons, leading to community outcry for adjustments.
Introduction of Regular Weapon Patches
Responding to player feedback, the developers at Blue Mammoth Games began to introduce regular balance patches aimed at toning down overpowered weapons and buffing underutilized ones. By 2018, weapons like the Lance and Axe, which had previously been underwhelming, received significant buffs to make them more competitive. This marked the beginning of a more systematic approach to weapon balancing.
Current Weapon Balancing Problems in Brawlhalla
While weapon balancing has improved over time, the issue persists, especially in high-level competitive play, where even slight imbalances can have significant effects.
Weapon Power Creep
One of the core issues is the power creep that occurs with new weapon introductions or buffs. As newer weapons and Legends are released, older ones often feel weaker by comparison. This leads to a shift in the meta, where certain weapons dominate tournaments and casual play. For example, the introduction of Greatsword saw it become the meta-defining weapon due to its string potential and overwhelming damage output.
Disparity Between Competitive and Casual Play
Another ongoing issue is the disparity between weapon effectiveness in competitive versus casual play. Weapons like Scythe or Gauntlets, which require technical expertise and precise inputs, are considered strong in the hands of skilled players. However, for casual players, these weapons often feel weak, leading to inconsistent performance across different player skill levels.
Analyzing Overpowered Weapons in the Current Meta
Several weapons currently dominate the meta, drawing criticism from players who feel the game lacks balance. These weapons often outshine others due to their damage potential, versatility, and lack of counterplay.
The Dominance of the Greatsword
The Greatsword has been a contentious weapon in Brawlhalla since its release. It offers extended string combos that deal massive damage and are difficult to escape once initiated. While it has been nerfed multiple times, many players still consider it overpowered due to its ability to control the pace of the game.
Lance and Its Zoning Potential
Another weapon frequently mentioned in balance discussions is the Lance. With its large hitboxes and zoning capabilities, the Lance allows players to control the battlefield and space opponents out effectively. Its ability to chain high-damage moves in quick succession makes it difficult for opponents to recover once they are caught in a combo.
Underpowered Weapons: The Struggle for Viability
While some weapons dominate the meta, others struggle to remain viable, particularly in competitive play. These weapons often lack the versatility needed to contend with more powerful choices.
The Bow’s Lack of Damage Output
Despite being a versatile weapon, the Bow is often criticized for its lack of damage output compared to weapons like the Hammer or Axe. While the Bow excels at controlling space and harassing opponents from a distance, it lacks the knockout power needed to finish off enemies, especially in ranked play.
Cannon’s Underwhelming Presence
The Cannon, another underutilized weapon, struggles with long recovery times on missed attacks, leaving players vulnerable to punishment. While it has strong combo potential, its predictability and difficulty in landing hits make it a less favorable choice, especially at higher ranks.
Developer Responses to Weapon Imbalance
The developers at Blue Mammoth Games have been proactive in addressing weapon balancing concerns, with each major patch focusing on tweaking weapon stats, hitboxes, and recovery frames.
Patch-by-Patch Adjustments
Each major patch generally brings weapon balance changes. For instance, after significant community feedback, the Greatsword received several nerfs to its string potential and damage output. Similarly, weapons like the Lance and Sword have seen adjustments aimed at reducing their dominance in the meta.
Listening to Community Feedback
Blue Mammoth Games also actively listens to the player base, utilizing feedback from forums, social media, and professional players to guide their balancing decisions. Their commitment to fostering a healthy competitive scene is evident through regular updates and direct engagement with the community.
The Role of Legends in Weapon Balancing
In addition to weapon balancing, the unique attributes of each Legend—such as their signature moves, speed, and defense—also influence the perceived balance of weapons.
Signature Move Synergy
Certain Legends have signature moves that greatly complement their weapon choices, making them feel overpowered in certain scenarios. For example, Thatch’s Blasters are considered particularly strong due to his high-damage signature attacks, which cover a large area and can KO opponents early.
Legend Stats and Their Impact
Legend stats, such as speed, defense, and dexterity, also play a crucial role in how balanced a weapon feels. A weapon that may seem overpowered in the hands of a fast Legend like Hattori may not be as effective when wielded by a slower Legend like Azoth. Thus, balancing weapons requires considering the Legend’s entire toolkit.
Competitive Players’ Perspective on Weapon Balancing
For competitive players, weapon balancing is of utmost importance as even slight imbalances can affect the outcome of matches and tournaments.
Meta Shifts in Tournaments
The competitive scene often experiences shifts in the meta with each balance patch. Weapons like Scythe and Gauntlets frequently rise to prominence, while others, like Orb or Bow, fall out of favor due to perceived weaknesses. Professional players adapt to these shifts, but imbalanced patches can lead to frustration when certain weapons feel too dominant.
Tactical Play vs. Weapon Strength
At high levels of play, weapon strength is often less about raw damage output and more about the tactical options it provides. Weapons like the Katars offer significant outplay potential through fast movement and quick attacks, but their lower damage output means they rely on players to consistently land hits to be effective.
Possible Solutions to Weapon Balancing in Brawlhalla
There are several potential solutions to the ongoing weapon balancing issues in Brawlhalla, some of which have been discussed within the community.
More Frequent Balancing Patches
One solution could be the introduction of more frequent balance patches. While Blue Mammoth Games already releases patches regularly, increasing the frequency could help address imbalances more swiftly and keep the meta from becoming stale.
Implementing a Weapon Ban System
Another potential solution is the introduction of a weapon ban system in competitive play. This would allow players to ban a specific weapon before matches, similar to how Legends are banned in certain fighting games. While this system might seem drastic, it could help mitigate frustration with overpowered weapons.
Conclusion
Weapon balancing in Brawlhalla remains a complex issue that affects both casual and competitive players. While the developers have made significant strides in addressing community concerns, ongoing challenges persist, particularly with weapons like the Greatsword and Lance. The key to maintaining a healthy meta lies in frequent balance patches, open communication between developers and players, and continued refinement of both weapons and Legends. With a growing competitive scene and a dedicated player base, the future of Brawlhalla’s weapon balancing will be crucial in shaping the game’s longevity and success.
.
